Home  Site Map  Source Page

Thomas William Simpkin

New York Times Reports
Monday 19 April 1920


The following text is copied from the archives of the New York Times and reports events following the murder by Thomas William Simpkin of the prominent New York surgeon, Dr. James W. Markoe.

DR. MARKOE FAMOUS IN HIS PROFESSION
Physician of J. Pierpont Morgan, Who Aided Him in Lying-In Hospital Work.

Dr. James Wright Markoe was rated by his associates in the medical profession as one of the foremost gynecologists in the country, and for the last twenty years he had taken an active part in the management of institutions specializing in that branch of medical science. He was considered an authority in gynecological surgery and his services as consulting surgeon were sought in hundreds of cases in the last ten years.

Before he had entered this branch of his profession, Dr. Markoe became one of the physicians for the family of the late J. Pierpont Morgan, and, although he had become famous as a specialist in later years, he retained this connection with the Morgan family. For more than twenty years he was the constant companion of J. Pierpont Morgan on his vacations, and associates of Dr. Markoe said yesterday that in some years he had spent as many as six months travelling as the private physician of the financier. He was not with Mr. Morgan when he died, however.

J.P. Morgan, the present head of the banking house, became greatly attached to the private physician of his father and emulated the example of the elder Morgan by calling upon Dr. Markoe whenever he was threatened with any ailment. The same intimate relation had been maintained by other members of the family.

When J.P. Morgan was shot by the maniac, Eric Muenter, in the Summer of 1915 after a struggle in the hallway of the Morgan Summer home at Glen Cove, L. I., a hurry call was sent to this city for Dr. Markoe. He was one of the first physicians to reach the Morgan home and, after attending the wounds, he remained with Mr. Morgan until he was out of danger. Muenter, who was known also as Holt, committed suicide a few days after the shooting by jumping from the roof of his cell in Nassau County jail at Mineola. He manifested similar maniacal tendencies shown yesterday in the shooting of Dr. Markoe.

A few months after Mr. Morgan recovered from the wounds of this attack he became ill with appendicitis, and again Dr. Markoe was summoned. He performed the operation, with Dr. H. H. McLyle. For some of the Morgan children he had been the only physician attending them since birth.

His Work in Hospital.

It was with the help of the late J. Pierpont Morgan that Dr. Markoe and a group of other noted surgeons who were interested in gynecology expanded the work of the Lying-In Hospital, at Seventeenth Street and Second Avenue. Dr. Markoe became medical director of the institution, and before his retirement, about three years ago, it had been made one of the best specialized institutions of its kind in the world. Course of study were established for graduate physicians, students of medicine and nurses, and the medical profession credits many of its advancements in obstretrical science to the efforts of the staff members of the institution.

Before he had begun to take an active interest in the kind of institution the Lying-In Hospital has become Dr. Markoe and other young physicians, who have since become famous, organized the work of the women’s dispensary at 314 Broome Street. Some of those who were associated with Dr. Markoe in this work were Dr. Samuel Lambert, who later became Dean of the College of Physicians and Surgeons; Dr. Austin Flint, the noted alienist and surgeon; Dr. J. Clinton Edgar and Dr. H. McM. Painter. For a long time before Mr. Morgan became interested in their work these surgeons carried on the work, all of it without charge to the patients, by their own efforts and at their own expense.

When Dr. Markoe and his associates took up the work at the Lying-In Hospital they maintained this so-called midwifery dispensary as one of the sub-stations, and its work on the east side has been expanded year by year without cost to needy families. Many of the worthy patients at the dispensary are taken to the Lying-In Hospital for treatment without cost to them.

Studied in Europe.

After his graduation from the College of Physicians and Surgeons, in 1885, Dr. Markoe went abroad to study in Munich and during his period of post-graduate work he developed his interest in gynecology and obstetrics. Upon his return he became the first house surgeon at the Sloane Hospital for Women, where he remained for several years. He went to the Broome Street Dispensary about 1890, but for many years maintained his connection with the Sloane Hospital and the Vassar Brothers Hospital in Poughkeepsie, where he was consulting gynecologist for many years. He was medical director at the Lying-In Hospital until about 1917, when he decided that he would devote the greater part of his time to his private practice.

Dr. Markoe came from a family of physicians. His father, Dr. Thomas Masters Markoe, was one of the noted physicians in this city fifty years ago and for decades was a member of the staff of the New York Hospital. His brother, Dr. Frank Markoe, also is a physician. Born in this city on July 19, 1862, Dr. Markoe was educated in the public schools and at St. Paul’s School at Concord, N.H. Except for brief periods out of the city in travel or study he had lived here all his life.

For more than thirty-five years Dr. Markoe had been a communicant and vestryman at St. George’s Church. It was in this same edifice that his marriage to Annette B. Wetmore took place on Nov. 22, 1894, and in this edifice also their only daughter, Annette, now Mrs. William J. Schieffelin, Jr. was baptized and married.

Dr. Markoe was a lecturer at the City College, Fellow of the Academy of Medicine, member of the county and State medical associations, and of the American College of Physicians and Surgeons, Society for the Relief of Widows and Orphans and several charitable organizations. His clubs were the Metropolitan, Century, Racquet and Tennis and New York Yacht. His home was at 12 West Fifty-fifth Street.

Herbert L. Satterlee, who had known Dr. Markoe for many years, said yesterday that, although most of the physician’s friends had forgotten that phase of his life, he was a good amateur athlete and one of the best amateur middleweight boxers of the ’80s. In later years Dr. Markoe had been interested in yachting and cruised frequently with Mr. Morgan.




Top